Our Watch Collection, Rated Out of 10 (2026)

Eight watches from the collection, scored on design, build, value and versatility, ranked from the everyday workhorse to the automatic flagship.

Last updated: June 2026

If you want one watch from the Adam & Westcott collection, the Lobinni Perpetual Calendar scores highest at 9 out of 10, thanks to its automatic Seagull movement, 316L stainless steel case and sapphire crystal. But the right watch depends on the look you want and the budget you set, and there are strong picks under $50. We scored eight watches across the collection on four things, design, build and movement, value, and versatility. Here is how each one rates.

How we scored

Each watch earns a mark out of 10 based on four equally weighted things: design (does it look more expensive than it is), build and movement (case material, crystal, quartz or automatic), value (what you get for the price), and versatility (how many outfits and occasions it covers). A 7 is a good watch with a clear job, an 8 is a standout in its lane, and a 9 is the one we would hand a first-time buyer without hesitation.

The collection, rated

Watch	Style	Standout spec	Price	Score
Lobinni Perpetual Calendar	Luxury automatic	Seagull 28-jewel automatic, sapphire	$169.98	9/10
Obsidian Matte Business	Minimalist dress	Numberless all-black dial, leather strap	$44.98	8.5/10
Roman Leather Dial	Dress complication	Moon phase, stainless steel case	$59.99	8.5/10
Phantom Steel GMT	Steel sports	GMT bezel, full steel bracelet	$39.99	8/10
Valenro Skeleton Automatic	Mechanical skeleton	Exposed self-winding movement	$69.98	8/10
Retro Multi-Dial Quartz	Retro chronograph look	Japan Epson movement, cream dial	$69.95	7.5/10
Bold Square Automatic	Statement square	46mm square dial, self-winding	$64.95	7.5/10
Sentinel Military Quartz	Rugged field	Military build, reliable quartz	$59.98	7/10

1. Lobinni Perpetual Calendar Watch, 9/10

The flagship, and the highest score in the collection. A 316L stainless steel case, a sapphire crystal that resists scratches, and a Seagull 28-jewel automatic movement put it in a different class to the quartz pieces below. The layered calendar dial reads as expensive, and at $169.98 it is the watch to own if you buy only one. Best for the man who wants a genuine automatic with real presence.

2. Obsidian Matte Business Watch, 8.5/10

The value standout. A numberless, all-black matte dial and a genuine leather strap give it a quiet-luxury look that costs far more elsewhere, yet it lands at $44.98. It reads as a deliberate, minimalist dress watch and pairs with everything from a suit to a tee. Best for the man who wants understated style on a budget.

3. Roman Leather Dial Watch, 8.5/10

The dress pick with a real talking point. A stainless steel case and leather band carry a moon phase complication that you rarely see at this price, and the Roman numerals keep it classic. It is the watch for weddings, dinners and the office. Best for the man who wants a dress watch with a bit of craft on the dial.

4. Phantom Steel GMT Watch, 8/10

The best everyday sports watch here, and remarkable value at $39.99. A GMT bezel, a clean sunray dial and a full stainless steel bracelet give it the all-rounder look that suits the office and the weekend. The red accent keeps it from feeling plain. Best for the man who wants one steel watch to wear daily.

5. Valenro Skeleton Automatic Watch, 8/10

The pick for mechanical character. A skeleton dial shows off the self-winding movement underneath, which is the kind of detail that makes a watch fun to own and wear. It leans vintage and looks best on leather with a smart-casual outfit. Best for the man who wants to see the mechanics tick.

6. Retro Multi-Dial Quartz Watch, 7.5/10

The everyday retro-chronograph look, with a warm cream dial, three sub-dials and a distressed leather strap. A Japan Epson quartz movement keeps it accurate and low-maintenance. It is more about looks than complication, and it nails the vintage-inspired vibe. Best for the man who wants character without going automatic.

7. Bold Square Automatic Watch, 7.5/10

The statement piece. A 46mm matte black square dial with oversized numerals and a self-winding mechanical movement makes a deliberate, confident impression. The size and shape will not suit every wrist or every outfit, which is the only thing that holds the score back. Best for the man who wants a watch people notice.

8. Sentinel Military Quartz Watch, 7/10

The rugged field watch, built for everyday knocks with a military-inspired look and dependable quartz movement. It does its job well and pairs naturally with casual and outdoor outfits. It is more utilitarian than refined, which is exactly the point. Best for the man who wants a tough, no-fuss daily beater.

The verdict

Best overall: the Lobinni Perpetual Calendar at 9/10, the only automatic with steel and sapphire in this group. Best value: the Obsidian Matte Business at 8.5/10 for under $50. Best dress watch: the Roman Leather Dial with its moon phase. Best everyday steel: the Phantom Steel GMT. Quartz watches win on price and low maintenance, automatics win on character and feel, so the right pick comes down to whether you want set-and-forget accuracy or a movement you can watch tick.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best Adam & Westcott watch?

The Lobinni Perpetual Calendar scores highest at 9 out of 10, with a 316L steel case, sapphire crystal and a Seagull automatic movement. For value, the Obsidian Matte Business at $44.98 is the standout.

Are quartz or automatic watches better?

Quartz watches are more accurate, cheaper and need almost no maintenance, while automatic watches offer mechanical character and never need a battery. Choose quartz for set-and-forget daily wear and automatic if you enjoy the craft.

What is a good first watch for a man?

A versatile, neutral piece you can wear with most outfits. The Obsidian Matte Business and the Phantom Steel GMT are both easy, affordable first watches, while the Lobinni is the upgrade pick if you want an automatic.

What does a moon phase watch do?

A moon phase complication shows the current phase of the moon on the dial. It is a classic, decorative touch that adds craft and character, as seen on the Roman Leather Dial Watch.

What size watch should a man wear?

Most men suit a 38mm to 42mm case, which sits cleanly under a cuff. Larger statement pieces like the 46mm Bold Square Automatic wear big, so they suit broader wrists and a more deliberate look.

Finishing the outfit around it? See how to wear a men's print shirt and how to choose a men's leather bag.