Our Watch Collection, Rated Out of 10 (2026)
Nine watches from the collection, scored out of 10 on their published specs, from a $39.99 GMT to a sapphire automatic.
Last updated: October 2026
The highest rated Adam & Westcott watch is the 
Lobinni Perpetual Calendar Watch at 9 out of 10, for its sapphire crystal, 316L steel case, Seagull 28 jewel automatic movement and 5 bar water rating at $169.98. Under $50, the 10 mm 
Obsidian Matte Business Watch scores 8.5 at $44.98.
How are the watches scored?
Each watch gets a mark out of 10 from four equal parts: design, build and movement, value for the price, and versatility. These are the Adam & Westcott team's own ratings of watches we sell, not an independent review, and every spec below comes from the watch's product page. A 7 does one job well; a 9 is the one we would hand a first time buyer.
How does every watch compare?
| Watch | Movement | Standout spec | Water | Price | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 Lobinni Perpetual Calendar Watch |
Automatic, Seagull 28 jewel | Sapphire crystal, 316L steel | 5 bar | $169.98 | 9/10 |
 Obsidian Matte Business Watch |
Quartz | 10 mm slim case | Not stated | $44.98 | 8.5/10 |
 Classic Dial Watch |
Quartz | Moon phase, luminous hands | 3 bar | $59.99 | 8.5/10 |
 Phantom Steel GMT Watch |
Quartz | GMT 24hr bezel, 11 mm case | 30 m | $39.99 | 8/10 |
 Bold Dial Sport Watch |
Quartz | Luminous hands, silicone strap | 3 bar | $39.99 | 8/10 |
 Valenro Skeleton Automatic Watch |
Automatic | Skeleton dial, no battery | Not stated | $69.98 | 8/10 |
 Retro Multi-Dial Quartz Watch |
Japan Epson quartz | Hardlex crystal, 3 sub-dials | 3 bar | $69.95 | 7.5/10 |
 Bold Square Automatic Watch |
Automatic | 46 mm square dial | Not stated | $51.99 | 7.5/10 |
 Sentinel Military Quartz Watch |
Quartz | Leather strap, date | Not stated | $59.98 | 7/10 |
Which watch scores highest, and why?
The Lobinni Perpetual Calendar Watch scores 9 because it is the only watch here with sapphire crystal, a 316L steel case and 5 bar water resistance together. The Seagull 28 jewel automatic movement winds itself, the layered calendar dial carries real presence, and a push button clasp keeps it secure. At $169.98 it also clears free shipping on its own.
316L steel case, sapphire crystal, Seagull 28 jewel automatic movement, 5 bar water resistance.
$169.98What is the best value watch?
The Obsidian Matte Business Watch scores 8.5 at $44.98, with a slim 10 mm case, a numberless dial and a genuine leather strap. At $39.99, two more score 8. The 
Phantom Steel GMT Watch adds a GMT 24hr bezel, a full steel bracelet and 30 m water resistance. The 
Bold Dial Sport Watch is the best-selling Adam & Westcott watch over the last 30 days, with luminous hands and a 3 bar rating.
Which is the best dress watch?
The 
Classic Dial Watch scores 8.5 at $59.99 for its moon phase complication, luminous hands and stainless steel case rated to 3 bar. It runs on quartz, so it keeps time without winding. If you want the slimmest option for a shirt cuff, the 10 mm Obsidian Matte Business Watch is the other choice.
Which watches are automatic?
Three: the Lobinni Perpetual Calendar Watch at $169.98, the 
Valenro Skeleton Automatic Watch at $69.98 and the 
Bold Square Automatic Watch at $51.99. The Valenro scores 8 for its skeleton dial and carved metal case. The Bold Square scores 7.5: its 46 mm square dial and matte black case make a statement, but that size will not suit every wrist or outfit.
Which watches score lowest, and why?
The 
Retro Multi-Dial Quartz Watch scores 7.5 and the 
Sentinel Military Quartz Watch scores 7, because each does one look well rather than many. The Retro Multi-Dial pairs a Japan Epson quartz movement and Hardlex crystal with a cream dial and 3 sub-dials at $69.95. The Sentinel is a plain military style quartz with a date window and leather strap at $59.98, built for casual days.
Frequently asked questions
Which Adam & Westcott watch scores highest?
The Lobinni Perpetual Calendar Watch at 9 out of 10: a 316L stainless steel case, sapphire crystal, a Seagull 28 jewel automatic movement and 5 bar water resistance for $169.98.
What is the best Adam & Westcott watch under $50?
The Obsidian Matte Business Watch at $44.98 scores 8.5, with a slim 10 mm case. The Phantom Steel GMT Watch and the Bold Dial Sport Watch both cost $39.99 and score 8.
Which Adam & Westcott watches are automatic?
Three in this list: the Lobinni Perpetual Calendar Watch at $169.98, the Valenro Skeleton Automatic Watch at $69.98 and the Bold Square Automatic Watch at $51.99. None needs a battery.
Which watch is best for water?
The Lobinni Perpetual Calendar Watch is rated 5 bar, the highest here. Most of the others are rated 3 bar or 30 m, which suits rain and hand washing rather than swimming.
Are these ratings an independent review?
No. They are the Adam & Westcott team's own ratings of watches we sell, scored on design, build, value and versatility from each watch's published specs.
Shopping with a budget in mind? the best automatic watches under $100 and our gifts for men guide for 2026.
Find your next watch
From a $39.99 GMT to a sapphire automatic, the full collection in one place.
Shop men's watchesFree shipping on orders over $99.